Wednesday, December 24, 2025

The Poom Rank Mirage: No Adult Black Belt Here

Bret Gordon's sole verifiable rank is a junior Taekwondo black belt (poom), which in actuality is far from an adult dan-grade credential.  Leaning on this childhood poom as his "black belt" foundation while claiming mastery across multiple arts falls woefully short of the pressure-tested shodan forged in 5–7 years of legitimate training.  These "kiddie" belts lack the maturity, depth, and yudansha responsibility that define real black belts. A poom rank certainly isn't a foundation to make up one's own style at the tender age of 16.

Kiddie Black Belts and Commercialized Dojos aren't Hard Training Environments

​Commercialization in the 1980s dramatically shortened martial arts belt timelines by prioritizing profit over traditional mastery, turning dojos into businesses reliant on frequent promotions. Tae Kwon do related "Kiddie" Black belt programs, as Bret indicates he is a product of, targeted kids aged 6-12 with simplified curricula, basic kicks, forms, and breaks—promising black belts in 12-18 months to boost retention and parental buy-in and severely watered down and omitted rigorous standards.

They bypassed real training time by conveniently watering down the art, substituting endless belt ceremonies, paperwork, and snack breaks.​​ Instead of hours drilling basics like proper ukemi, kihon-ippon kumite, or tanden-driven force generation, these fantasy factories prioritize "graduations" every three months—complete with cake and photo ops—to keep revenue flowing.

Fast-track black belt programs in Taekwondo rose in the 1980s due to aggressive commercialization of dojos in the U.S., where owners shifted from traditional training to business models emphasizing quick promotions for revenue. Many U.S. TKD schools and McDojos targeted kids with "fast-track" poom (junior black belt) paths, promising ranks in 12-18 months via simplified poomsae, basic kicks, and board breaks rather than full sparring or self-defense depth. Parents signed these contracts locking in fees, cementing these “schools” as profit-driven and not merit-based.

True Path to Shodan

Serious dojos demand 5–7 years for shodan, with traditional ones pushing 8–10, building unhurried command of skill, timing, mechanics, and mindset. Rushing yields delusion over depth—1-2 year "black belts" expose zero functional edge.

Memorization Fails Pressure

Kata and combos? Any rote learner nails them quick. True mastery flows instinctively under resistance, techniques crushing live foes—this emerges only from years of brutal mat time and nothing else.

Bret Gordon’s martial arts journey reads like the tragic tale of a man who spent his formative years bobbing and weaving around the one experience that forges real budo character: the well-deserved, attitude-adjusting ass whupping. In his own posts he readily admits he never trained anywhere long. This indicates that he conveniently missed out on anything that was actually tough, difficult or presented challenge.

In a proper dojo, bad habits and big egos are corrected by the oldest universal language in combat sports: getting folded in half by someone smaller, older, and far less impressed with you than you are with yourself. Instead of this, Gordon appears to have trained early on in a mcdojo, a climate-controlled fantasy kwoon, where the mat was apparently bubble-wrapped for his protection, garnering his poom rank in 2000.

Judging by his public self created mythology, Bret seems to have sidestepped the day a beginner learns that watching Steven Seagal movies is not a defensive technique. In most people, it produces humility, better guard position, and a deep respect for cardio. In Gordon’s case, instead of getting punched in the face, he simply awarded himself another rank certificate or got daddy to buy it. 

The Fast Track Black Belt - Road to Ineptitude not Supremacy

Fast-track black belts from McDojos or junior poom programs routinely crumble against legitimate shodan holders who earned their rank through 5–7 years of rigorous, pressure-tested training. These mismatches expose glaring gaps in technique, conditioning, and composure, often leaving the quick-rank holders embarrassed on the mats.

Mat Reality Check

Traditional dojo students drill fundamentals relentlessly, yielding polished stances, timing, and resistance-proof skills that overwhelm McDojo grads who get tapped out fast or get thrown when real randori hits, their lack of depth exposed to the nth degree. Poom or Junior ranks prioritize memorization not real live application, so adult sparring reveals zero grappling savvy or endurance against battle-hardened opponents.

McDojo schools, training and habits offer no real depth in any martial art and prove that 1-2 year "black belt mastery" is relegated to nothing more than a participation trophy. An attendance award that represents delusion, not dominance or technical supremacy.